Here they are: every single movie we have completely spoiled since the show began in the summer of 2016! Those marked with “P” were picked by original co-host Paul Kastava, those marked with “K” were chosen by Keith, and those that I (Jay) nominated are marked “J”. If a guest or listener suggested a film, their name is included as well.
Smell the spoilage!
MOVIES WE HAVE COMPLETELY SPOILED
- 9 to 5 – J – Episode #97
- 11:14 – K – Episode #62
- 12 Angry Men – P – Episode #25
- 21 – K – Episode #168
- 25th Hour – K – Episode #141
- 47 Meters Down – K – Episode #181
- 1408 – K – Episode #159
- Absolutely Fabulous: The Movie – J & Melissa McDowell – Episode #11
- Alice, Sweet Alice – J & Erin Casteneda – Episode #83
- All About Eve – J – Episode #46
- Alligator – J – Episode #177
- Amèlie – J & Kellie Arnold – Episode #129
- American Psycho – J & Christine Adams – Episode #29
- An American Werewolf in London – J – Episode #99
- Ankle Biters – P – Episode #8
- Apocalypto – K – Episode #86
- Apple, The – J – Episode #10
- Assault On Precinct 13 – J – Episode #197
- Audition – J – Episode #16
- Audrey Rose – J & Erin Casteneda – Episode #73
- Babadook, The – J & Knives Monroe – Episode #8
- Baby Face – J – Episode #24
- Bad Boys – Paul (4th Anniversary Show) – Episode #104
- Bad Words – K – Episode #56
- Basic Instinct – J – Episode #178
- Bay of Blood, J – Episode #77
- Beautiful Girls – Jennifer Hamrich – Episode #15
- Belfast – J & Kellie Arnold – Episode #157
- Ben – J & Erin Casteneda – Episode #91
- Beyond The Valley Of The Dolls – J – Episode #118
- Big Doll House, The – J – Episode #23
- Billy Madison – P – Episode #45
- Bird – P – Episode #22
- Bird With The Crystal Plumage, The – J – Episode #63
- Black Christmas – J – Episode #36
- The Blob (1958) – J – Episode #136
- The Blob (1988) – J – Episode #136
- Blood and Black Lace – J – Episode #4
- Blood Feast – J – Episode #126
- Blood Fest – J – Episode #89
- Bloodsport – K – Episode #13
- Body Heat – J – Episode #171
- Body Snatchers – J – Episode #95
- Boiler Room – K – Episode #78
- Boondock Saints, The – K – Episode #101
- Born Yesterday – J – Episode #60
- Bound – J & Cassandra Weyandt – Episode #179
- Boy in the Striped Pajamas, The – K – Episode #64
- Boy Who Could Fly, The – K – Episode #194
- Bride Of Frankenstein – J – Episode #150
- Bronx Tale, A – P – Episode #35
- Burnt Offerings – J & Erin Casteneda – Episode #77
- Cabaret – J – Episode #81
- Cabin in the Woods, The – J & Kellie Arnold – Episode #52
- Caged Heat – P – Episode #49
- Can’t Stop The Music – J – Episode #43
- Changeling, The – J & Shawna West – Episode #85
- Chasing Trane: The John Coltrane Documentary – P – Episode #42
- Chopping Mall – J – Episode #74
- Christmas Evil (aka Better Watch Out) – J – Episode #61
- Christmas Horror Story, A – K – Episode #139
- Citizen Kane – J & Knives Monroe – Episode #142
- Classic Horror Story, A – K – Episode #137
- Clue – J & Kellie Arnold – Episode #188
- Con Air – P – Episode #20
- Cookie’s Fortune – J & Cassandra Weyandt – Episode #103
- Cool Runnings – P – Episode #41
- Crazy Fat Ethel (Criminally Insane) – J & K – Episode #100
- Crime Story – P – Episode #29
- Crooklyn – P – Episode #7
- Dark Blue – P – Episode #50
- Dark Harvest – J – Episode #187
- Das Experiment – P – Episode #11
- Dead End – P – Episode #4
- Death Becomes Her – J – Episode #79
- Death Race 2000 – J – Episode #18
- Death Wish – P – Episode #18
- Deep Red – J – Episode #12
- Dial Code Santa Claus aka Deadly Games – J – Episode #139
- Dirty Work – P – Episode #1
- Disaster Artist, The – P – Episode #
- Diving Bell and The Butterfly, The – K – Episode #92
- Disaster Artist, The – J – Episode #36
- Don’t be a Menace to South Central while Drinking your Juice in the Hood – P – Episode #12
- Don’t Look Now – J – Episode #124
- Double Indemnity – J – Episode #171
- Draft Day – P – Episode #30
- Eating Raoul – J – Episode #9
- Ender’s Game – K – Episode #133
- Eraserhead – J – Episode #175
- Escape from New York – J – Episode #33
- Eternal Sunshine of the Spotless Mind – P – Episode #40
- Evil Dead, The – J – Episode #6
- Evil Dead 2: Dead By Dawn – J – Episode #38
- Faculty, The – J – Episode #28
- Fan, The – P – Episode #44
- Faster, Pussycat! Kill! Kill! – J – Episode #55
- Female Trouble – J – Episode #5
- Flash Gordon – J – Episode #71
- Flight – K – Episode #88
- Fly, The (1958) – J – Episode #120
- Fly, The (1986) – J – Episode #120
- For Love Of The Game – P – Episode #130
- Frailty – J – Episode #17
- Frankenstein – J – Episode #150
- Freaks – J – Episode #183
- Freddy Got Fingered – K – Episode #68
- Freeway – K – Episode #74
- Frequency – K – Episode #121
- Friday the 13th – J – Episode #14
- Friday the 13th Part Two – J – Episode #77
- Frighteners, The – P – Episode #32
- Funny Games – Brad Bell – Episode #33
- Gentlemen Prefer Blondes – J – Episode #167
- Ghost World – P – Episode #26
- Giant – J – Episode #39
- Girl On The Train, The – K – Episode #172
- Gods And Monsters – J – Episode #152
- Gone Girl – K – Episode #84
- Goodbye Lover – J – Episode #106
- Greasy Strangler, The – J – Episode #20
- Greatest Showman, The – K – Episode #155
- Gremlins – K – Episode #113
- Grey Gardens – J – Episode #42
- Grindhouse (Planet Terror and Death Proof) – J & Kellie Arnold – Episode #9
- Gummo – P – Episode #47
- Halloween 1978 – J – Episode #31
- Halloween 3 – J – Episode #8
- Halloween 2018 – K – Episode #57
- Halloween Kills – K – Episode #135
- Happy Gilmore – P – Episode #6
- Heavyweights – K – Episode #107
- Hedwig and the Angry Inch – J – Episode #53
- Hellbent – J – Episode #161
- Hero – K – Episode #114
- Hidden, The – J – Episode #26
- High School High – P – Episode #23
- Higher Learning – K – Episode #129
- Homicidal! – J & Teri Castagne – Episode #19
- Hoosiers – K – Episode #123
- Hot Shots! – P – Episode #15
- House On Haunted Hill (1959) – J – Episode #164
- House On Haunted Hill (1999) – J – Episode #164
- How To Marry A Millionaire – J – Episode #167
- Humanoids From The Deep (aka Monster) – J – Episode #48
- Illusionist, The – K – Episode #72
- Invasion Of The Body Snatchers (1956) – J – Episode #67
- Invasion Of The Body Snatchers (1978) – J – Episode #73
- It’s A Wonderful Knife – J & Kellie Arnold – Episode #191
- Jackie Brown – J & Mandey Shiver – Episode #76
- KIDS – P – Episode #48
- Killer Klowns from Outer Space – K – Episode #7
- Kissing A Fool – P – Episode #24
- Kite Runner, The – K – Episode #103
- La La Land – J – Episode #22
- Lady Terminator – J – Episode #3
- Ladybugs – P – Episode #49
- Last Of Sheila, The – J – Episode #146
- Last Shark, The – J & Erin Casteneda – Episode #180
- Leaves Of Grass – K – Episode #119
- Legend – J – Episode #51
- Legend Of Hell House, The – J & Erin Casteneda – Episode #185
- Let The Right One In – J & Shawna West – Episode #158
- Letter To Three Wives, A – J – Episode #132
- License to Drive – K – Episode #52
- Life Aquatic with Steve Zissou, The – P – Episode #21
- Lion – K – Episode #54
- Lionheart – P – Episode #13
- Little Giants – K – Episode #170
- The Little Girl Who Lives Down The Lane – J & Erin Casteneda – Episode #169
- Little Monsters – J – Episode #196
- Love Actually – K – Episode #61
- Love Witch, The – J – Episode #58
- Mac And Me – J & Paul Kastava – Episode #190
- Made – P – Episode #38
- Magnificent Seven, The – K – Episode #82
- Major League 3: Back To The Minors – P – Episode #43
- Mallrats – P – Episode #40
- Man In The Moon, The – K – Episode #131
- March Of The Wooden Soldiers (aka Babes In Toyland) – P – Episode #36
- Meet Me In St. Louis – J – Episode #87
- Melancholia – K – Episode #147
- Midnight Hour, The – J – Episode #161
- Midsommar – J & Knives Monroe – Episode #93
- Million Dollar Arm – P – Episode #17
- Miracle Mile – J – Episode #193
- Moonrise Kingdom – J – Episode #21
- Moulin Rouge! – J – Episode #162
- My Bloody Valentine – J – Episode #65
- Mr. Mike’s Mondo Video – J – Episode #29
- Needful Things – K – Episode #105
- Night Of The Demons – J – Episode #135
- Nightmare On Elm Street – J – Episode #41
- No Escape – P – Episode #3
- One Cut Of The Dead – J – Episode #110
- Others, The – J & Leanne Wright & Jennifer Hamrick – Episode #35
- Outbreak – K – Episode #90
- PCU – P – Episode #9
- Pest, The – P – Episode #19
- Pink Flamingos – J – Episode #75
- Piranha – J – Episode #128
- Plan 9 From Outer Space – J – Episode #125
- Platform, The – K – Episode #98
- Poltergeist 3 – K – Episode #100
- Pootie Tang – P – Episode #51
- Poseidon Adventure, The – J & Erin Casteneda – Episode #114
- Program, The – P – Episode #14
- Psycho – J – Episode #134
- Psycho II – J – #160
- Rare Exports – J – Episode #11
- Remember the Titans – P – Episode #31
- Return Of The Living Dead – J – Episode #108
- Road House – P – Episode #37
- Rocky IV – K & P – Episode #111
- Role Models – K – Episode #166
- Room, The – J – Episode #34
- Rounders – K – Episode #94
- Run Lola Run – J – Episode #100
- Sadness, The – K – Episode #153
- Saltburn – J & Kellie Arnold – Episode #195
- Samurai Cop – K – Episode #126
- Sandlot, The – P – Episode #16
- Santa Claus Conquers The Martians – J – Episode #165
- Satan’s Little Helper – J – Episode #32
- Saving Christmas – K – Episode #125
- Scary Stories To Tell In The Dark – J – Episode #187
- School Of Rock – K – Episode #186
- Shaun of the Dead – J – Episode #25
- She’s All That – K – Episode #198
- Sidekicks – K – Episode #192
- Silence, The – K – Episode #174
- Silent Night, Deadly Night – J – Episode #112
- Simple Plan, A – K – Episode #66
- Singin’ In The Rain – J – Episode #182
- Singles – P – Episode #34
- Skinamarink – J & K – Episode #168
- Sleepaway Camp – J – Episode #2
- Sleepers – P – Episode #46
- Sour Grapes – P – Episode #33
- South Central – P – Episode #39
- Spice World – J – Episode #69
- Stalag 17 – P – Episode #26
- Stay Tuned – K – Episode #145
- Staying Alive – J – Episode #45
- Stepford Wives, The – J & Erin Casteneda – Episode #156
- Steve Zissou and The Life Aquatic – P – Episode #21
- Substitute, The – P – Episode #28
- Sunrise – J – Episode #173
- Sunset Blvd. – J – Episode #59
- Superbad – J & K – Episode #163 (for Paul)
- Survive Style 5+ – J – Episode #1
- TAG – K – Episode #76
- Taking of Pelham One Two Three, The – P – Episode #10
- Tales of Halloween – J – Episode #83
- Terrifier – K – Episode #109
- Thing, The – J – Episode #102
- Thing From Another World, The – J – Episode #102
- Thinner – K & Shawna West – Episode #117 (our 200th movie!)
- This Is Spinal Tap – Jay & Shawna West – Episode #154
- Timecop – J – Episode #13
- Timecrimes- J – Episode #37
- To Die For – J – Episode #138
- To Kill A Mockingbird – J – Episode #116
- Town That Dreaded Sundown, The – J & Erin Casteneda – Episode #140
- Train To Busan – K – Episode #23
- Trick ‘r Treat – J – Episode #7
- Troll 2 – J – Episode #44
- True Lies – P & J – Episode #17
- Ugly Sweater Party – J – #165
- Under Siege – P – Episode #5
- Valley of the Dolls – J – Episode #26
- Vampire’s Kiss – J & Kellie Arnold – Episode #122
- Very Bad Things – K – Episode #70
- Violent Night – J – Episode #191
- Voyage Of The Rock Aliens – J – Episode #148
- Wait Until Dark – J & Erin Casteneda – Episode #109
- Waking Life – K – Episode #80
- Wanted – J – Episode #104
- Warriors, The – P – Episode #2
- What About Bob? – K – Episode #75
- What We Do In The Shadows – J – Episode #40
- Whatever Happened to Aunt Alice – Teri Castagne – Episode #4
- When Evil Lurks – K – Episode #189
- Where The Crawdads Sing – Laura Stroud – Episode #184
- Whiplash – K – Episode #176
- White Water Summer – K – Episode #128
- The Wild and Wonderful Whites of West Virginia – K – Episode #96
- WNUF Halloween Special, The – J – Episode #57
- Women, The – J – Episode #15
- Xanadu – J – Episode #30
- Young Frankenstein – J – Episode #151
- Zaat – Shawna West – Episode #130
- Zero Hour! – J – Episode #47
- Zombie – J – Episode #50