Here they are: every single movie we have completely spoiled since the show began in the summer of 2016! Those marked with “P” were picked by original cohost Paul Kastava, those marked with “K” were chosen by Keith, and those that I (Jay) nominated are marked “J”. If a guest or listener suggested a film, their name is included as well.

Smell the spoilage!

MOVIES WE HAVE COMPLETELY SPOILED

1. 9 to 5 – J – Episode #97
2. 11:14 – K – Episode #62
3. 12 Angry Men – P – Episode #25
4. 25th Hour – K – Episode #141
5. 1408 – K – Episode #159
6. Absolutely Fabulous: The Movie – J & Melissa McDowell – Episode #11
7. Alice, Sweet Alice – J & Erin Casteneda – Episode #83
8. All About Eve – J – Episode #46
9. Amèlie – J & Kellie Arnold – Episode #129
10. American Psycho – J & Christine Adams – Episode #
11. An American Werewolf in London – J – Episode #99
12. Ankle Biters – P – Episode #8
13. Apocalypto – K – Episode #86
14. Apple, The – J – Episode #10
15. Audition – J – Episode #16
16. Audrey Rose – J & Erin Casteneda – Episode #73
17. Babadook, The – J & Knives Monroe – Episode #8
18. Baby Face – J – Episode #24
19. Bad Boys – Paul (4th Anniversary Show) – Episode #104
20. Bad Words – K – Episode #56
21. Bay of Blood, J – Episode #77
22. Beautiful Girls – Jennifer Hamrich – Episode #15
23. Belfast – J & Kellie Arnold – Episode #157
24. Ben – J & Erin Casteneda – Episode #91
25. Beyond The Valley Of The Dolls – J – Episode #118
26. Big Doll House, The – J – Episode #23
27. Billy Madison – P – Episode #45
28. Bird – P – Episode #22
29. Bird With The Crystal Plumage, The – J – Episode #63
30. Black Christmas – J – Episode #36
31. The Blob (1958) – J – Episode #136
32. The Blob (1988) – J – Episode #136
33. Blood and Black Lace – J – Episode #4
34. Blood Feast – J – Episode #126
35. Blood Fest – J – Episode #89
36. Bloodsport – K – Episode #13
37. Body Snatchers – J – Episode #95
38. Boiler Room – K – Episode #78
39. Boondock Saints, The – K – Episode #101
40. Born Yesterday – J – Episode #60
41. Boy in the Striped Pajamas – K – Episode #64
42. Bride Of Frankenstein – J – Episode #150
43. Bronx Tale, A – P – Episode #35
44. Burnt Offerings – J & Erin Casteneda – Episode #77
45. Cabaret – J – Episode #81
46. Cabin in the Woods, The – J & Kellie Arnold – Episode #52
47. Caged Heat – P – Episode #49
48. Can’t Stop The Music – J – Episode #43
49. Changeling, The – J & Shawna West – Episode #85
50. Chasing Trane: The John Coltrane Documentary – P – Episode #42
51. Chopping Mall – J – Episode #74
52. Christmas Evil (aka Better Watch Out) – J – Episode #61
53. Christmas Horror Story, A – K – Episode #139
54. Citizen Kane – J & Knives Monroe – Episode #142
55. Classic Horror Story, A – K – Episode #137
56. Con Air – P – Episode #20
57. Cookie’s Fortune – J & Cassandra Weyandt – Episode #103
58. Cool Runnings – P – Episode #41
59. Crazy Fat Ethel (Criminally Insane) – J & K – Episode #100
60. Crime Story – P – Episode #29
61. Crooklyn – P – Episode #7
62. Dark Blue – P – Episode #50
63. Das Experiment – P – Episode #11
64. Dead End – P – Episode #4
65. Death Becomes Her – J – Episode #79
66. Death Race 2000 – J – Episode #18
67. Death Wish – P – Episode #18
68. Deep Red – J – Episode #12
69. Dial Code Santa Claus aka Deadly Games – J – Episode #139
70. Dirty Work – P – Episode #1
71. Disaster Artist – P – Episode #
72. Diving Bell and The Butterfly, The – K – Episode #92
73. Disaster Artist, The – J  – Episode #36
74. Don’t be a Menace to South Central while Drinking your Juice in the Hood – P – Episode #12
75. Don’t Look Now – J – Episode #124
76. Draft Day – P – Episode #30
77. Eating Raoul – J – Episode #9
78. Ender’s Game – K – Episode #133
79. Escape from New York – J – Episode #33
80. Eternal Sunshine of the Spotless Mind – P – Episode #40 
81. Evil Dead, The – J – Episode #6
82. Evil Dead 2: Dead By Dawn – J – Episode #38
83. Faculty, The – J – Episode #28
84. Fan, The – P – Episode #44
85. Faster, Pussycat! Kill! Kill! – J – Episode #55
86. Female Trouble – J – Episode #5
87. Flash Gordon – J – Episode #71
88. Flight – K – Episode #88
89. Fly, The (1958) – J – Episode #120
90. Fly, The (1986) – J – Episode #120
91. For Love Of The Game – Paul Kastava – Episode #130
92. Frailty – J – Episode #17
93. Frankenstein – J – Episode #150
94. Freddy Got Fingered – K – Episode #68
95. Freeway – K – Episode #74
96. Frequency – K – Episode #121
97. Friday the 13th – J – Episode #14
98. Friday the 13th Part Two – J – Episode #77
99. Frighteners, The – P – Episode #32
100. Funny Games – Brad Bell – Episode #33
101. Ghost World – P – Episode #26
102. Giant – J – Episode #39
103. Gods And Monsters – J – Episode #152
104. Gone Girl – K – Episode #84
105. Goodbye Lover – J – Episode #106
106. Greasy Strangler, The – J – Episode #20
107. Greatest Showman, The – K – Episode #155
108. Gremlins – K – Episode #113
109. Grey Gardens – J – Episode #42
110. Grindhouse (Planet Terror and Death Proof) – J & Kellie Arnold – Episode #9
111. Gummo – P – Episode #47
112. Halloween 1978 – J – Episode #31
113. Halloween 3 – J – Episode #8
114. Halloween 2018 – K – Episode #57
115. Halloween Kills – K – Episode #135
116. Happy Gilmore – P – Episode #6
117. Heavyweights – K – Episode #107
118. Hedwig and the Angry Inch – J – Episode #53
119. Hellbent – J – Episode #161
120. Hero – K – Episode #114
121. Hidden, The – J – Episode #26
122. High School High – P – Episode #23
123. Higher Learning – K – Episode #129
124. Homicidal! – J & Teri Castagne – Episode #19
125. Hoosiers – K – Episode #123
126. Hot Shots! – P – Episode #15
127. House On Haunted Hill (1959) – J – Episode #164
128. House On Haunted Hill (1999) – J – Episode #164
129. Humanoids From The Deep (aka Monster) – J – Episode #48
130. Illusionist, The – K – Episode #72
131. Invasion Of The Body Snatchers (1956) – J – Episode #67
132. Invasion Of The Body Snatchers (1978) – J – Episode #73
133. Jackie Brown – J & Mandey Shiver – Episode #76
134. KIDS – P – Episode #48
135. Killer Klowns from Outer Space – K – Episode #7
136. Kissing A Fool – P – Episode #24
137. Kite Runner, The – K – Episode #103
138. La La Land – J – Episode #22
139. Lady Terminator – J – Episode #3
140. Ladybugs – P – Episode #49
141. Last Of Sheila, The – J – Episode #146
142. Leaves Of Grass – K – Episode #119
143. Legend – J – Episode #51
144. Let The Right One In – J & Shawna West – Episode #158
145. Letter To Three Wives, A – J – Episode #132
146. License to Drive – K – Episode #52
147. Life Aquatic with Steve Zissou, The – P – Episode #21
148. Lion – K – Episode #54
149. Lionheart – P – Episode #13
150. Love Actually – K – Episode #61
151. Love Witch, The – J – Episode #58
152. Made – P – Episode #38
153. Magnificent Seven, The – K – Episode #82
154. Major League 3: Back To The Minors – P – Episode #43
155. Mallrats – P – Episode #40
156. Man In The Moon, The – K – Episode #131
157. March Of The Wooden Soldiers (aka Babes In Toyland) – P – Episode #36
158. Meet Me In St. Louis – J – Episode #87
159. Melancholia – K – Episode #147
160. Midnight Hour, The – J – Episode #161
161. Midsommar – J & Knives Monroe – Episode #93
162. Million Dollar Arm – P – Episode #17
163. Moonrise Kingdom – J – Episode #21
164. Moulin Rouge! – J – Episode #162
165. My Bloody Valentine – J – Episode #65
166. Mr. Mike’s Mondo Video – J – Episode #29
167. Needful Things – K – Episode #105
168. Night Of The Demons – J – Episode #135
169. Nightmare On Elm Street – J – Episode #41
170. No Escape – P – Episode #3
171. One Cut Of The Dead – J – Episode #110
172. Others, The – J & Leanne Wright & Jennifer Hamrick – Episode #35
173. Outbreak – K – Episode #90
174. PCU – P – Episode #9
175. Pest, The – P – Episode #19
176. Pink Flamingos – J – Episode #75
177. Piranha – J – Episode #128
178. Plan 9 From Outer Space – J – Episode #125
179. Platform, The – K – Episode #98
180. Poltergeist 3 – K – Episode #100
181. Pootie Tang – P – Episode #51
182. Poseidon Adventure, The – J & Erin Casteneda – Episode #114
183. Program, The – P – Episode #14
184. Psycho – J – Episode #134
185. Psycho II – J – #160
186. Rare Exports – J – Episode #11
187. Remember the Titans – P – Episode #31
188. Return Of The Living Dead – J – Episode #108
189. Road House – P – Episode #37
190. Rocky IV – K & P – Episode #111
191. Room, The – J – Episode #34
192. Rounders – K – Episode #94
193. Run Lola Run – J – Episode #100
194. Sadness, The – K – Episode #153
195. Samurai Cop – K – Episode #126
196. Sandlot, The – P – Episode #16
197. Santa Claus Conquers The Martians – J – #165
198. Satan’s Little Helper – J – Episode #32
199. Saving Christmas – K – Episode #125
200. Shaun of the Dead – J – Episode #25
201. Silent Night, Deadly Night – J – Episode #112
202. Simple Plan, A – K – Episode #66
203. Singles – P – Episode #34
204. Sleepaway Camp – J – Episode #2
205. Sleepers – P – Episode #46
206. Sour Grapes – P – Episode #33
207. South Central – P – Episode #39
208. Spice World – J – Episode #69
209. Stalag 17 – P – Episode #26
210. Stay Tuned – K – Episode #145
211. Staying Alive – J – Episode #45
212. Stepford Wives, The – J & Erin Casteneda – Episode #156
213. Steve Zissou and The Life Aquatic – P – Episode #21
214. Substitute, The – P – Episode #28
215. Sunset Blvd. – J – Episode #59
216. Superbad – J & K – Episode #163 (for Paul)
217. Survive Style 5+ – J – Episode #1
218. TAG – K – Episode #76
219. Taking of Pelham One Two Three, The – P – Episode #10
220. Tales of Halloween – J – Episode #83
221. Terrifier – K – Episode #109
222. Thing, The – J – Episode #102
223. Thing From Another World, The – J – Episode #102
224. Thinner – K & Shawna West – Episode #117 (our 200th movie!)
225. This Is Spinal Tap – Jay & Shawna West – Episode #154
226. Timecop – J – Episode #13
227. Timecrimes- J – Episode #37
228. To Die For – J – Episode #138
229. To Kill A Mockingbird – J – Episode #116
230. Town That Dreaded Sundown, The – J & Erin Casteneda – Episode #140
231. Train To Busan – K – Episode #23
232. Trick ‘r Treat – J – Episode #7
233. Troll 2 – J – Episode #44
234. True Lies – P & J – Episode #17
235. Ugly Sweater Party – J – #165
236. Under Siege – P – Episode #5
237. Valley of the Dolls – J – Episode #26
238. Vampire’s Kiss – J & Kellie Arnold – Episode #122
239. Very Bad Things – K – Episode #70
240. Voyage Of The Rock Aliens – J – Episode #148
241. WNUF Halloween Special, The – J – Episode #57
242. Wait Until Dark – J & Erin Casteneda – Episode #109
243. Waking Life – K – Episode #80
244. Wanted – J – Episode #104
245. Warriors, The – P – Episode #2
246. What About Bob? – K – Episode #75
247. What We Do In The Shadows – J – Episode #40
248. Whatever Happened to Aunt Alice – Teri Castagne – Episode #4
249. White Water Summer – K – Episode #128
250. The Wild and Wonderful Whites of West Virginia – K – Episode #96
251. Women, The – J – Episode #15
252. Xanadu – J – Episode #30
253. Young Frankenstein – J – Episode #151
254. Zaat – Shawna West – Episode #130
255. Zero Hour! – J – Episode #47
256. Zombie – J – Episode #50